top of page
  • April Schrader, CPDT-KA

Training Vs Torture: The Ethics of Dog Training Tools

When it comes to training our beloved canine companions, the options can seem overwhelming. Amidst the plethora of training tools available, some have sparked controversy due to their potential for harm and questionable effectiveness. Among these tools are prong collars, choke chains, and shock collars. I


In this blog, we'll delve into why these tools are unnecessary, why educated dog trainers avoid them, and the more humane and effective alternatives to consider.

The Problem with Prong Collars, Choke Chains, and Shock Collars:

Prong collars, choke chains, and shock collars are often marketed as quick fixes for behavioral issues. However, their use raises ethical concerns and can lead to unintended consequences. These tools are designed to inflict discomfort or pain as a form of correction. Not only can this damage the bond between you and your dog, but it also has the potential to exacerbate behavioral problems and increase anxiety, fear, and aggression.


The Science Behind Aversive Dog Training Tools:

Scientific evidence overwhelmingly supports the notion that tools like chain, prong, and shock collars cause pain and discomfort to dogs. Research consistently indicates that the application of pressure, force, or electric stimulation from these tools triggers stress responses, elevated cortisol levels, and often, negative associations. Studies have found physiological signs of distress, including increased heart rates and avoidance behaviors when these aversive tools are used. As responsible dog owners, it's crucial to consider the pain and discomfort these tools inflict on our beloved pets and opt for training methods that prioritize their well-being and emotional state.


Understanding the Drawbacks:

  1. Physical and Emotional Harm: Prong collars and choke chains operate on the principle of applying pressure or pain to discourage unwanted behavior. This can lead to physical injuries, including damage to the trachea, neck, and spine. Furthermore, these tools can create a negative emotional association with training, causing your dog to become anxious or fearful.

  2. Pain as a Deterrent: Shock collars deliver an electric shock to the dog's neck when activated by a remote. This method relies on causing pain to interrupt undesired behavior. However, studies show that pain-based training methods can lead to aggression and increased stress in dogs.

Why Educated Dog Trainers Avoid Them:

Professional dog trainers who are up-to-date with modern training methodologies often choose to steer clear of prong collars, choke chains, and shock collars for several reasons:

  1. Ethics and Welfare: Ethical trainers prioritize the emotional and physical well-being of the dog. They understand that positive reinforcement methods are not only effective but also compassionate.

  2. Science-Based Training: Modern training approaches are grounded in scientific understanding of canine behavior. Shock and punishment-based methods go against the principles of these evidence-based approaches.

  3. Long-Term Impact: Educated trainers recognize that these tools may suppress behavior temporarily but fail to address the underlying causes. Positive reinforcement methods address behavior holistically, leading to long-lasting and positive changes.

Understanding the Reality: Pain and Sensitivity


In the world of dog training, there might be conflicting opinions on the use of prong collars, choke chains, and shock collars. Some trainers might demonstrate these tools on themselves to prove they aren't painful, but this overlooks a crucial fact: dogs and humans have vastly different anatomies. A dog's skin is significantly thinner and more sensitive than human skin. What might be bearable for a human can be incredibly uncomfortable or even painful for a dog.


Regardless of the assurances given, it's essential to consider the dog's perspective. We cannot accurately gauge their experience based on our own sensations. The discomfort or pain these tools can inflict on a dog cannot be discounted just because a trainer didn't feel the same intensity. Your dog is the one wearing the tool, experiencing the sensations, and enduring the consequences. As responsible dog owners, it's our duty to prioritize their well-being and comfort above all else.


In Conclusion:


In a world where empathy and understanding are paramount, choosing training methods that respect your dog's sensitivity is a true testament to the bond you share. Opting for humane, positive reinforcement techniques not only shows your commitment to your dog's welfare but also aligns with the evolving landscape of dog training that emphasizes compassion, science, and the pursuit of a harmonious partnership.


By choosing a professional dog trainer who emphasizes humane and evidence-based techniques, you're not only fostering a harmonious relationship with your furry friend but also contributing to the betterment of the training world as a whole. 🐾 For professional guidance on effective and compassionate dog training, reach out to us at Best Buddy Dog Trainer text/call 301-231-1907 or email jeff@bestbuddydogtrainer.com. Together, let's create a harmonious and joyful learning experience for your beloved companion. 🐶💙

11 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All
bottom of page